Mathematics Atlas

How Proof Is Made

Mathematics Atlas

Disputed Statements

Claims this atlas currently marks as unsettled or as tested and found false. A debated fact is one scholars hold competing positions on; a debunked one has been checked against the record and found not to hold. Both are kept in view rather than quietly smoothed over, with the reasoning that put each one where it stands.

24 statements.

Archimedes, Birth Year287 BCE

Archimedes, Mathematicians

Standing

Concerns Birth Year

Currently States 287 BCE

Calculated from the Byzantine writer John Tzetzes' claim, centuries later, that Archimedes lived 75 years; not independently confirmed.

Source MacTutor History of Mathematics Archive

Central Limit Theorem, Proof Year1810

Central Limit Theorem, Theorems

Standing

Concerns Proof Year

Currently States 1810

The theorem has no single proof date. Abraham de Moivre proved a special case, the normal approximation to the binomial distribution, in 1733. Pierre-Simon Laplace substantially generalized it in 1810, the year given here as the theorem's general form. Aleksandr Lyapunov supplied the first fully rigorous general conditions in 1901.

Source MacTutor History of Mathematics Archive

Euclid, Birth Year325 BCE

Euclid, Mathematicians

Standing

Concerns Birth Year

Currently States 325 BCE

No birth record survives; 325 BCE is a commonly cited scholarly estimate derived from his known activity under Ptolemy I (reigned from 305 BCE), not a firm date.

Source MacTutor History of Mathematics Archive

Euclid, Death Year265 BCE

Euclid, Mathematicians

Standing

Concerns Death Year

Currently States 265 BCE

No death record survives; this is a commonly cited estimate, not a firm date.

Source MacTutor History of Mathematics Archive

Euler's Identity, Proof Year1748

Euler's Identity, Theorems

Standing

Concerns Proof Year

Currently States 1748

The identity follows from Euler's formula, published in his 1748 Introductio in analysin infinitorum, though historical records suggest Euler may never have explicitly written down this exact identity in this form himself.

Source Euler's Identity (Wikipedia)

Fundamental Theorem of Calculus, Proof Year1666

Fundamental Theorem of Calculus, Theorems

Standing

Concerns Proof Year

Currently States 1666

Newton's own working dates to 1665-1666; he published only decades later. Leibniz developed an independent version in the 1670s and published first, in 1684. Priority between them was never settled to both sides' satisfaction.

Source Encyclopaedia Britannica, Mathematics

Infinitude of Primes, Proof Year300 BCE

Infinitude of Primes, Theorems

Standing

Concerns Proof Year

Currently States 300 BCE

Dated to the compilation of Euclid's Elements; no more precise date for the individual proposition survives.

Source MacTutor History of Mathematics Archive

John Napier, Defining ContributionDiscovered logarithms and published the first account of them in 1614 as Mirifici Logarithmorum Canonis Descriptio, replacing laborious multiplication and division in astronomical and navigational calculation with addition and subtraction.

John Napier, Mathematicians

Standing

Concerns Defining Contribution

Currently States Discovered logarithms and published the first account of them in 1614 as Mirifici Logarithmorum Canonis Descriptio, replacing laborious multiplication and division in astronomical and navigational calculation with addition and subtraction.

Napier's 1614 publication is conventionally credited as the origin of logarithms; see the dissent recorded against this fact for Jost Burgi's independent, later-published claim.

Source John Napier (Wikipedia)

Joseph-Louis Lagrange, Defining ContributionLagrange stated, for permutations of polynomial variables, that the number of distinct polynomials obtained is always a factor of n!, the special case later generalized into the theorem bearing his name.

Joseph-Louis Lagrange, Mathematicians

Standing

Concerns Defining Contribution

Currently States Lagrange stated, for permutations of polynomial variables, that the number of distinct polynomials obtained is always a factor of n!, the special case later generalized into the theorem bearing his name.

Lagrange's name is attached to the theorem that a finite group's subgroup order divides the group's order, but he stated only a special case about permutations of polynomial variables; the general statement for all groups was proved later, by Camille Jordan in 1861.

Source Lagrange's Theorem, Group Theory (Wikipedia)

Lagrange's Theorem (Group Theory), Proof Year1861

Lagrange's Theorem (Group Theory), Theorems

Standing

Concerns Proof Year

Currently States 1861

Lagrange himself stated only a special case, about permutations of polynomial variables, in his 1771 paper. The theorem was generalized to all groups later, through the work of Gauss in 1801 and Cauchy in 1844, and finally proved for all permutation groups by Camille Jordan in 1861.

Source Lagrange's Theorem, Group Theory (Wikipedia)

Leonardo of Pisa, Birth Year1170 CE

Leonardo of Pisa, Mathematicians

Standing

Concerns Birth Year

Currently States 1170 CE

No firm birth record survives; c. 1170 is the commonly cited scholarly estimate.

Source MacTutor History of Mathematics Archive

Leonardo of Pisa, Death Year1240 CE

Leonardo of Pisa, Mathematicians

Standing

Concerns Death Year

Currently States 1240 CE

No firm death record survives; estimates commonly range from 1240 to 1250.

Source MacTutor History of Mathematics Archive

Muhammad ibn Musa al-Khwarizmi, Birth Year780 CE

Muhammad ibn Musa al-Khwarizmi, Mathematicians

Standing

Concerns Birth Year

Currently States 780 CE

No firm birth record survives; c. 780 CE is the commonly cited scholarly estimate.

Source MacTutor History of Mathematics Archive

Muhammad ibn Musa al-Khwarizmi, Death Year850 CE

Muhammad ibn Musa al-Khwarizmi, Mathematicians

Standing

Concerns Death Year

Currently States 850 CE

No firm death record survives; c. 850 CE is the commonly cited scholarly estimate.

Source MacTutor History of Mathematics Archive

Pi, Origin Year250 BCE

Pi, Concepts

Standing

Concerns Origin Year

Currently States 250 BCE

Dates Archimedes' rigorous bounding method; numerical approximations of the ratio itself are considerably older (Babylonian and Egyptian sources, second millennium BCE) and less precisely datable.

Source MacTutor History of Mathematics Archive

Pierre de Fermat, Birth Date1607-10-31

Pierre de Fermat, Mathematicians

Standing

Concerns Birth Date

Currently States 1607-10-31

Some sources give 1601; the discrepancy traces to confusion between Fermat and an older half-brother of the same name who died in infancy. 1607 is MacTutor's and most modern scholarship's preferred date.

Source MacTutor History of Mathematics Archive

Pierre de Fermat, Birth Year1607

Pierre de Fermat, Mathematicians

Standing

Concerns Birth Year

Currently States 1607

Some sources give 1601; see the birth-date note.

Source MacTutor History of Mathematics Archive

Pythagoras, Birth Year570 BCE

Pythagoras, Mathematicians

Standing

Concerns Birth Year

Currently States 570 BCE

No contemporary record survives; c. 570 BCE is the commonly cited scholarly estimate, reconstructed from later, sometimes unreliable, biographical traditions.

Source MacTutor History of Mathematics Archive

Pythagoras, Death Year495 BCE

Pythagoras, Mathematicians

Standing

Concerns Death Year

Currently States 495 BCE

No contemporary record survives; this is a commonly cited scholarly estimate, not a firm date.

Source MacTutor History of Mathematics Archive

Pythagoras, BirthplaceSamos, an Ionian Greek island

Pythagoras, Mathematicians

Standing

Concerns Birthplace

Currently States Samos, an Ionian Greek island

Widely repeated in later sources but resting on tradition rather than a contemporary record.

Source MacTutor History of Mathematics Archive